Clairifying Claires
John McCabe
What is accomplished with oysters in the claires of the Marennes-Oléron
region should certainly be considered very special. However,
the term "claire" is very flexible, as there are lots
of different kinds of "claires" used in French oyster
cultivation and elsewhere in the world. Just because an oysterman
has a "claire" does not mean that his oysters are now
going to taste just like the claire-refined oysters from Marennes-Oléron
or that his claire was ever even intended to "fatten and
refine" his oysters. It may have an entirely different purpose
for his oysters.
A "claire" is simply any more
or less saline water compound or basin of varying size, usually
square or rectangular, where oysters are temporarily deposited
for one or more reasons. The size of the water compound is about
1,800 ft² (approx. 500 m²), some are larger and some
considerably smaller. They are usually quite shallow, the depth
rarely exceeding 20 inches (about 50 cm). A water compound of
this type can be located in the shallow portion of the intertidal
zone. A claire can also be situated on land - sometimes even
inside a building, usually connected to the sea in one way or
another, possibly with pipes, valves, and pumps. Claires can
also describe a series of simple saline water pools, the result
of soil excavation in suitable ground, sometimes connected to
man-made canals which can be opened or closed. A dike or wall
of some sort is usually built around the perimeter (piled up
soil, boards, concrete...) to contain or at least slow the run-off
of the water. Many claires are also made up entirely of concrete.
Inset image: This
French post card from the early 19th century depicts oyster compounds
in the inter-tidal zone of Cancale. Click image to enlarge
The principal purpose of almost all claires
is to improve plain "ocean oysters" in one way or another,
possibly even in a number of ways. The utilization of a claire
can thus be quite simplistic or, as in the case of the Marennes-Oléron
region, be elevated to a form of art in the cultivation process.
"Clair" simply means "clear",
and the most rudimentary application of a claire is the purification
of an oyster. Oysters are exposed to clean water for a period
of time, during which they naturally purge any kind of impurities
(mud, sand...). Some modern claires serve as quarantine areas
of sorts, where the oysters filter water which has been treated
to be void of any marine bacteria or other potentially harmful
agent. A claire can also serve as an easily accessible holding
area for oysters ready for market, as claires are largely or
even completely unaffected by the rhythm of the tides. Almost
invariably the water level in claires can be more or less controlled.
By lowering the water level and exposing the oysters to air,
oysters can literally be trained to stay closed for long periods
of time. Oysters, whose adductor muscles have been conditioned
over time in this manner will prove superior when the time comes
to be shipped long distances or to remain fresh in a vendor's
seafood case for an extended amount of time.
Claires can also be used to improve the flavor, meat weight,
texture, and sometimes even the color of the oyster meat by temporarily
offering the oysters a special feeding environment in the respective
claire.
In some areas, where temperature extremes
are seasonally prevelant, certain types of "claires"
can also help oysters survive. Thanks to a truly fantastic design
by nature, the formidable shell fortress makes every culinary
oyster species remarkably resilient to temperature extremes -
to a point. Some oyster species are tougher in this respect than
others. For instance, the Eastern oyster (Crassostrea virginica)
and Pacific oyster (Crassostrea gigas) are proven survivalists
of the first order. The European oyster (Ostrea edulis)
and Olympia oyster (Ostrea lurida or Ostrea Conchaphila)
are more sensitive. However, even a gladiator like the Pacific
oyster can only take that much. During extreme cold spells, it
will hunker down and reduce its metabolic rate to almost to zero.
During extreme heat, it will bank on its prominently cupped shell
design, capable of holding much fluid to help maintain a tolerable
temperature and moisture level. At a certain point, however,
either extreme will get too much for an oyster to bear. Oystermen
somberly refer to this point as "winter kills" or "summer
kills".
Some oystermen in cold areas such as Germany
and Scotland have resorted to bringing all their Pacific oysters
"in from the cold" during the winter months. They are
then deposited in somewhat warmer water pools inside buildings.
Likewise, in the late 1800s, American oystermen on the West Coast,
built diked compounds in the intertidal zone of South Puget Sound
(around Totten Inlet). These "claires" of sorts, helped
their Olympia oysters survive the extended exposure to winter
chills, compounded by the seasonally low tides during the night.
Maintaining an insulating layer of water above the oysters made
all the difference between life and death of the Olympia oysters.
There are some striking similarities between these "claires"
of Puget Sound and the claires of Marennes-Oléron - although
they serve different purposes.
In Marennes-Oléron, however, quite
the opposite climatic problem exists. These French oystermen
struggle with (occasionally massive) "summer kills".
While the hot summer sun delights tourists taking a pleasant
dip in the cool Atlantic Ocean, countless oysters in thousands
of mesh bags are baking on cultivation racks exposed to the blazing
sun, for hours on end, at low tide. These oysters are fighting
for their lives. To compound matters, Pacific oysters spawn in
the summer months. After spawning, they are weakened considerably
and thus particularly vulnerable. The oysters in the claires,
covered by an insulating sheet of water, are provided with better
protection from the blazing sun. Nonetheless, the claires of
Marennes-Oléron solve very little when massive summer
kills occasionally strike the oyster population of this region.
The principle purpose of claires around Marennes-Oléron
is thus not to help oysters survive the occasional ravages of
summer heat, but rather to fatten them naturally and greatly
improving their taste.